Outline of New System

Author: Mark Forster | Created: 2010-02-1 11:49 | Last Activity: 2010-02-5 15:20

Original Post

2010-02-1 11:49
Just to draw your attention to my blog post which gives the outline of the new system.

Reply by SimonW

2010-02-1 12:42
Intriguing.

I like the auto-dismissal aspect - I'd started to force this in AF4 by only allowing myself to consider an item six times before it was dismissed.

I'm treating my current AF4 closed & open lists as active until I reach 8th Feb.

Reply by Jim (Atlanta)

2010-02-1 13:19
Thanks for sharing, Mark! I'm in a weird spot in the school year, so I think I'll let others jump in and try this out first. I'll spend the month clearing the decks, getting a new diary/calendar, follow the discussion and either start this off in March (because the shortened month of Feb. makes this weird for me--maybe I'll just treat it as a 4 wk thing?) or as soon as school is out.

Again, thanks!

Reply by Avrum

2010-02-1 13:41
Questions about new system:

<< 1. You need a page-a-day diary >>

Fine.

<< 2. All new tasks are entered on the page which is one calendar month...>>

Huh? I often have "new tasks" that need to be done today, latest tomorrow. As well, responding to a new client must happen today, latest tomorrow. Where would I place these items?

<< 3. All re-entered tasks are entered on the page which is one week from today. >>

So even though I finish a task, I must renter the task a week from today. What about a task that I work on in the AM, and want to continue working on in the PM?

<<5. All active pages are treated as if they were one long list and you continue to circulate round them doing the tasks that stand out.>>

Are the "active pages" today's date... I'm confused.

<< 6. All tasks which are on pages earlier than today’s date have expired. They are dead, done for, dismissed, deceased.>>

I like this.

Any help would be appreciated.

Reply by Klaus

2010-02-1 14:11
Hi Avrum,

let me give your questions a shot:

I interpret the new System as beeing an Autofocus list with built in dismissal dates. Every task remains active for at least one month. Once you start working on something, you only get a week to continue. All pages later than today are active, all pages earlier are dismissed. The way I understand it is that the calendar is not serving a daily planning purpose but is only serving as an automatic dismissal or deletion mechanism.

Put differently: if you have taken on an obligation and haven't started working on it within a month, then there is possibly something wrong with it. This means that you need to analyze what is wrong.

The proposed system is clearly a task management system and not a time management system, despite being run inside a calendar.

Oh, and to your #3, once a task is finished, you take it from the list.

Hope this helps,

Klaus

Reply by Jay

2010-02-1 14:28
Mark
Thanks for the outline-quite intriguing.
Can I ask what to do with new projects that need working or
or completion before a month from current date?
viz urgent/pressing projects or tasks.
Thanks again
Jay

Reply by Jay

2010-02-1 14:36
Oh,I think I get it!
Are the entries actually deadlines (rather than actual work done) that you see when you
look through the diary?
I am going to try it for sure,but am worried if I will
miss a deadline if there are too many items
that need completion before the month-do you take action on these
anyway(common sense rule) and then reenter them as per rules?
Thanks again Mark
Jay

Reply by AndreasE

2010-02-1 14:38
I understand that you ENTER new tasks on a page that is 1 month away, but WORKING from the list means going through ALL pages from today to this page 1 month away (31 pages at the most) and working on whatever task stands out.

You work as long as you feel like, but this feeling might change once you have internalized that RE-ENTERING means that now you only have 1 WEEK to pick it up again.

Hmm.

I guess I'm more the AF type. At least this new rule set does not ignite the "hey wow cool" feeling in me that reading the original AF rule set did. I'm curious how this will work for others, but in the moment I stay with my slightly adapted AF3 system...

Reply by Jonaz in Stockholm

2010-02-1 14:48
Klaus - thank you for putting it so clearly.

Jay - I think the dates are to be considered as "dismissal deadlines", not actual *project* deadlines.

And as someone pointed out; Franklin Coveys 2-page diary now makes sense :-)

/Jonaz

Reply by Jacqueline

2010-02-1 15:14
It sounds like a great idea for dismissal !

The only thing I don't understand is why one doesn't just write things down on the current day, re-write on the next day you work on it so you only keep bringing it forward as you work on it, go back to previous days to choose tasks as well as desired/inspired, then delete anything that's on any page more than a month old.

It also seems you'd have to really watch the phrasing of tasks. Big, multi-month projects would have to be chunked down, which is probably a good thing anyway.

Reply by Avrum

2010-02-1 15:19
<>

Jacqueline - your idea is quite sound.

However as someone mentioned on the blog portion of this site... the new system is starting to morph into your average to-do list with built-in dismissal.

Reply by Ulrich J

2010-02-1 15:20
I like this "dismissal deadline" very much. I'm working with an index-card based system which consists of a tickler, an AF part, and - since the last few months - a kind of "backward tickler". Unactioned items, mostly ideas, are allowed to stay for four weeks in the "backward tickler" before they drop off into an archive. The idea is to allow a kind of incubation time, since ideas need time to grow and form into themes or actions.

What I like about the new System is that it has this 4-week-incubation-time built in, and that unactioned items are removed from the list automatically. So I just rearranged my cards to represent AF5, or whatever it will be called. In addition, I will keep my classic tickler which feeds cards into the list on a daily basis. Since these are mostly routine jobs, I plan to add them to the current day, instead of one month ahead.

For the moment, I'm quite happy. It feels as if Mark had incorporated my vague attempt into a well-thought system...

Reply by Ilse

2010-02-1 16:28
I'm very bad with sticking to an organized list. A1 to A4 never worked for me. A list has only been a list for me. Getting messy in 15 min and all the rules forgotten.

Now, the new systems seems to speak to me. I actually like it very much, and not because it's new and shiny. I'm ready to try it. Thank you Mark for posting it today, because yesterday I outlined my own system, which is different but merges very well with your idea. I can start practicing both and will see how it goes.

I only need to keep my lists neat.

Reply by Donna

2010-02-1 16:37
Has Mark abandoned the idea of a closed list? I thought that was one of the main features of DIT. That was the part of DIT that I was looking forward. Knowing how much work I have on my plate today.

Reply by Nicole

2010-02-1 16:44
My initial reaction was the same as with AF1-4: no way that's gonna work. But thinking it over I see some interesting things:

* one long list that you can process in whatever way seems suitable
* automatic dismissal, as in AF2 ("the marching line of doom" as someone called it). In AF2 the automatic dismissal process was too slow for me, I can see how it would work better in this new system
* still a closed list, although it doesn't look like it: today's page can't be added to! So if nothing else that's what you should work on to call it a day without dismissing them.
* being able to see how much work comes in each day, and how much I'm clearing every day

So I think I'll be trying this for a few months...

Reply by slothbear

2010-02-1 16:58
Ulrich -- thanks for those thoughts. I also have an index card system for routine tasks. I was using AF and the Routine Cards separately, but I'll try merging them now.

I can almost see the solution for adding a DIT/closed list/current initiative feature. Much like the Daily Routines you add to Today (or keep in the front), I could have a card for Current Initiative (which starts on top Every Day). Then a 2nd card in the stack for today's closed list, culled from a review of all cards at the end of the previous day. Only a few choice (or urgent) items would make it to this list. I'd let the system work its magic with the rest. That way I'd still get the Warm Feeling of Finished List at the end of the day.

Sure, I'll be duplicating some items, but my memory is good enough for that. When I next see the *done* item elsewhere in the stack, I'll just remove it or tick it off.

If I were using a page-a-day diary or my beloved Field Notes, I'd use 2 sticky notes, as I did with previous AF systems.

Reply by Jim (Atlanta)

2010-02-1 17:09
Name ideas for new system::

Future Focus

Forward Focus

Catch and Release
(because, like a fisherman, you're "catching" up a bunch of tasks and then "releasing" them into the future to be worked with--ok, that's a little lame, but it's better than "Do It, Um, Before It Expires...)

Any other ideas?

Reply by Mike

2010-02-1 17:26
Hi Mark,

O.K. So ....

>>> But in the case of the new DIT2/AF5 system, I think it might be more helpful to have other people working on it with me at the same time so that we can share our experiences of it together.

So what I am going to do now is to share the basic outline of what I’m doing now, so others can run with it and see what they can make of it. I’m not going to go into much detail because I think that would destroy the purpose of the exercise - the detail should appear from our experience of working the system. <<<

I like your thinking Mark. The only thing I think has already become evident is that some terms are a bit unclear.

>>> This is what it consists of:

1. You need a page-a-day diary with plenty of lines. Also some form of bookmarking for today’s date and the two entry pages (see below) - though turned down page corners are probably quite sufficient. <<<

I now get why you need so many lines. Everything you work on and don't complete is getting dumped on to a page where you already added all new tasks that came up on that day. The light dawns ;-)

>>> 2. All new tasks are entered on the page which is one calendar month from today’s date. Example: Today’s date is February 1st. New tasks are entered on the page for March 1st. Tomorrow I will enter new tasks on March 2nd and so on. <<<

Here is the first point where I see that we need some clarification. It SEEMS as if you can't start working on something new until a month ahead. What I think you are intending is that this system looks FORWARD for work, rather than BACKWARD, as the AF systems did. IOW, you are not continually scanning the past, but scanning the future, as it were. I'm not sure how much of a change this really is, but I'll bet the psychological effects will turn out to be significant.

As noted by others, this comes down an implied rule: "You start work on a task within one month." The effect is that you can't ignore a task for a month and still think you have any intention of doing it at all. Nice.

>>> 3. All re-entered tasks are entered on the page which is one week from today. So any task I re-enter today (Monday February 1st) goes on the page for for next Monday (February 8th). Tomorrow (Tuesday) they will go on the page for next Tuesday 9th and so on. <<<

As noted, this comes down an implied rule: "You must continue work on a task within one week." The intention is that if you don't do anything on a task within a week, you need to consider what is going wrong, slipping, etc. Nice.

>>> 4. Nothing is ever entered on any page, other than the pages currently one month and one week from today’s date. <<<

O.K. There is the closed list people have been hankering for ;-) The only difference seems to be (and again, I have not read your DIT books, but they are ordered and in the mail -- see, I'm not TERMINALLY stubborn, though my wife would challenge that ;-) that one can't PLAN a days' work ... which is what I gathered the essence of DIT was.

You fundamental "grass catcher" is going to be one month hence, and no matter how long or short the day, or if it falls on a weekend or not, it is going to have all that work piled on. In addition, incomplete tasks will also be dumped there a week before you reach it, thus all those lines. When you get there, you are very probably going to have a TON of work to do. So I can see some possible problems there.

SUGGESTION: Should we distinguish between weekends and weekdays in this system. IOW, will it be problematic to add work tasks to a weekend simply because the date falls that way? The converse is also true.

>>> 5. All active pages are treated as if they were one long list and you continue to circulate round them doing the tasks that stand out. <<<

I think we need to define ACTIVE PAGES. I'm assuming that this means TODAY plus all pages FORWARD? This really does have the feel of an upside down AF list ;-)

If this is the definition of "active pages" it changes the idea of "closed list" a bit. IOW, you are working on today's "closed list" plus the "closed lists" for the next six days, plus the "open list" for the seventh day, plus the "closed lists" for the next 21 days (or whatever), plus the "open list" for one month ahead. It certainly sounds more confusing than it actually is. Now I'm starting to think that the concept of "closed list" really has lost its effect.

>>> 6. All tasks which are on pages earlier than today’s date have expired. They are dead, done for, dismissed, deceased. <<<

Mark, could you come up with a different word for "dismissed"? ROTFLMAO ;-) Never let it be said that you don't learn from feedback ;-)

SUGGESTION: I'm assuming that we are going to put into effect some kind of AF like dismissal rule. IOW, was your thinking that things just kind of "expire" or that we go through some kind of review where we yellow line so the ones that expired stand out for future consideration, and deliberately reconsider other tasks to be moved forward one week?

>>> The thinking behind this is that you can put anything you like into the system. If you do nothing about it, it will remain there for a month and then expire. If at any time you commit yourself to a task by taking some action on it, you are put under increased pressure to get it finished by being given only seven calendar days to do some more work on it. Of course many tasks are done in one go, so can be deleted without being re-entered.

That’s all you need to get started. <<<

Great. I like it. It makes a lot of sense and your thinking about this way of approaching tasks is inspired. It is also a good reason to continue to call it "autofocus" ... it still has the effect of "automatically focusing" one.

SUGGESTION: We probably need to consider how to transition to this system. I suppose I could date the next 30+ pages (skipping the dates for the next six days) then treat my entire back pages as if they were on today's page, pretend that the next week is all that backlog, and then a week later I should be fully operational? Does that make sense to anyone?

This really does sound like fun ;-) Thanks Mark.

Reply by Sarah

2010-02-1 18:04
I'd been thinking I wasn't going to try the new system because my schedule is so unpredictable that the un-dated-ness of AF works very well for me. But... now I'm fighting the temptation to go and date a month's worth of pages in my AF book because I have truly urgent work for this afternoon.

I second Mike's question about how to transition from whichever iteration of AF we're using to this new system.

Reply by Christian G.

2010-02-1 18:06
“Has Mark abandoned the idea of a closed list?”

Donna, as I would see it: Today's page is somehow a closed list. Everything not tackled today (and subsequently either finished or carried forward by 7 days) will be dismissed automatically. And you can not add any new items on today’s page.

“The only thing I don't understand is why one doesn't just write things down on the current day”

Jacqueline, I think that’s part of the automatic dismissal. If something new comes up, you have one month to tackle it. Once you have started working on it, but not finishing it in one go, you have 7 days time to pick it up again.

But I must admit, I haven’t started the system yet. Just wonder about two little modifications (ahh, the tweaks again):
• Daily recurring tasks: have it on today’s page, finish it and cross it off, put the next instance on tomorrow’s page (not the page which is one week from today)
• Tasks with a deadline: I would put them on the page for the respective deadline date

Mark, any comments on my ideas?

Reply by Mike

2010-02-1 18:16
Christian,

I would expect that Mark might say use a calendar for the date senstive tasks, but since you are already using a calendar, I'd write them in some distinctive way on the appropriate day. Of course, you'd then have to scan ahead to avoid missing.

Recurent tasks: if you want to put them in this system, I'd say that they'd be the exception to the rule of not putting anything on any other page ... OR ... since this is one long list that you are cycling through, you'll get to that page a week hence and see them there. Unless you feel you really need to see them listed on the exact day they need to be done. If that is the case, I'd put them on the correct page, or simply take them OUT of this system. I have reminder lists and cards that are no part of this system. For example, I have a list of things my wife likes me to pack in her lunch in the morning. I have grocery shopping lists. None of that goes into the AF list. Nor does "brush teeth", "take show". LOL ;-) There are just some things that don't NEED management ;-)

Reply by Mike

2010-02-1 18:18
Sarah,

Start on day 6. One week from today. That is the first day you can enter ANYTHING on.

Reply by Mike

2010-02-1 18:19
I should have said: Start on the date of Feb 8!

Reply by Ken

2010-02-1 18:45
Hi,

OK, isn't this really as simple as:

+ New tasks get entered on the list with a 30 day expiration period.
+ Re-entered tasks get entered on the list with a 7 day expiration period.
+ Unactioned tasks expire after 30 or 7 days, respectively, and simply get deleted.

I think referencing a calendar confused people when these three rules seem to sum it up. Thoughts?

Reply by Nicole

2010-02-1 18:47
Mike,

about entering your current tasks: my tasks are all on dated pages, so I have a record of when I entered a task in AF4. I intend to transfer all those tasks into the corresponding pages one month later in the new system. It's not exactly as in the new system, because it doesn't take into account whether a task was reentered or not, but for most tasks still living in my AF4 list it would be okay.

Reply by Nicole

2010-02-1 18:50
Ken,

I think your summary is correct. The advantage of a calendar is that you don't have to keep track of when you entered a task or whether it was a re-entered task or not; you just write the task on the day it's going to expire.

I agree using a calendar could confuse people into thinking this is a plan-your-day system, but I think I would get used to that pretty quickly, especially when keeping this system separate from my actual calendar.

Reply by Jacqueline

2010-02-1 19:08
There might be logic to this due to approach vs. avoidance behaviours or personalities and procrastination according to new research (ie. most people who procrastinate are motivated by negative consequences).

http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/ulterior-motives/201001/no-problem-i-ll-have-it-done-next-week

http://iprocrastinate.libsyn.com/index.php?post_id=566235

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-1 19:17
Avrum:

I assume your original questions have now been answered either on this thread or on the blog thread?

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-1 19:23
Donna:

<>

Every page is a closed list, except the 1-week and 1-month pages, and each page has a different degree of pressure resulting from its nearness to the current day.

Reply by David Drake

2010-02-1 19:26
Hi Mark,

I take it one enters tasks that have to be done today on today's date?

-David

Reply by Mike

2010-02-1 20:42
David,

Either they go on AF 30 days from now, as per instruction, or you don't do them in AF.

Reply by David Drake

2010-02-1 20:50
Hi Mike,

I guess I don't understand this. If one has let's say three tasks that MUST be done TODAY without fail, why can't you just write those in today's page? I understand all of the other tasks, but this part does not make sense to me.

-David

Reply by Mike

2010-02-1 20:54
And another thing ;-)

I'm thinking it makes more sense to work with the "grass catcher page" as 1 MONTH ahead rather than 30 days. So, for example, 1 Mar is one MONTH after 1 Feb, but only 29 days. If you see what I mean. Using a month all I have to do is pick the same day as today but next month.

Reply by David Drake

2010-02-1 21:01
Mark,

Please comment here. One does not put things that have to be done today on today's date? I don't mean things that one would like to do, I mean things that REALLY have to be done today. Otherwise, it does not make sense to me.

-David

Reply by Mike

2010-02-1 21:01
David,

First of all you CAN do anything you like! ;-) But if you are trying to adhere to the spirit of how this new system works don't see the dates as having ANYTHING to do with a calendar. The two dates are just there to put pressure on you to get working on stuff. So the input page (grass catcher in my terms) is one month forward not because things need to be done then, but as an AUtOMATIC dismissal mechanism. If you don't work on those tasks within a month they need to go. Likewise for the week forward, if you don't CONTINUE working on an unfinished task, you need to be goosed!

Now if a task has a DUE DATE, what have we done with ANY AF system? We have put it OUTSIDE of the system and onto a calendar. Do the same here. OR, if you want to give a double meaning to the dates on the pages of your book, go ahead and put it in your dated AF book but I'd put it somewhere different on the page, like in a box or something. Or write it in passionate purple ;-)

Reply by David Drake

2010-02-1 21:05
Okay, I see your point, Mike. Now I do remember Mark commenting somewhere that if there is a task that has to be done on a certain day, one could think about entering it on that day, but put it in brackets so that it is distinguished from the other tasks.

Is this reasonable? Yes, I can do whatever I want, but I do want to work in the spirit of the system.

-Daivd

Reply by Norman U.

2010-02-1 21:09
Common sense + trying the system out for a while on paper and throughout your day would eliminate most of these questions and comments.

If you have to do something today? Do you really need an answer on how to handle this?

Before you reply please note your intention to do so 30 days from now. Work through your list(s) until responding to this comment merits the energy and time above all other actions you could be taking in that moment.

Do the same for every comment or question you think wants to be posted here.

Reply by Mike

2010-02-1 21:13
David,

If I were you, my driving consideration would be what is the most error free way of doing it. For ME that would be sticking with one book. In fact, I plan to put dated items in my AF book. I mostly use an electronic reminder for things like that. My iPhone calendar, for example. But since I have my nose in my AF book most of the time, it makes sense to write due date items on the correct page of the AF book right at the top in RED with a box around them.

As you are, I want stick with the spirit of AF5, but it needs to work for ME. And if it is not in my face I might overlook it.

Reply by David Drake

2010-02-1 21:24
Thanks, Norman. But I really do not appreciate your sarcasm. That was uncalled for.

-David

Reply by Simon H

2010-02-1 21:25
I think this whole thing has become a joke.

Reply by David Drake

2010-02-1 21:31
No, it is not a joke. It sounds like a good system and people simply have questions. As to Norman's sarcasm, of course I know how to handle work that needs to be done today. I will hold my education up against yours any day of the week. I was trying to see where to write things down -- that is it -- no more.

-David

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-1 22:00
Mike:

<< Your fundamental "grass catcher" is going to be one month hence, and no matter how long or short the day, or if it falls on a weekend or not, it is going to have all that work piled on. In addition, incomplete tasks will also be dumped there a week before you reach it, thus all those lines. When you get there, you are very probably going to have a TON of work to do. So I can see some possible problems there. >>

No, that's not going to be the case. It really doesn't make any different whether the 1-month point falls on a weekday or not. It's just the start of a one month period in which the task has got to be done. If you've left it for 29 days and have only just realised it's the weekend tomorrow, that's just poor planning!

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-1 22:03
Mike (again):

<< SUGGESTION: I'm assuming that we are going to put into effect some kind of AF like dismissal rule. IOW, was your thinking that things just kind of "expire" or that we go through some kind of review where we yellow line so the ones that expired stand out for future consideration, and deliberately reconsider other tasks to be moved forward one week? >>

I thought about this, but didn't want to put it in for definite at this stage. I'll probably see how people feel about it once it's actually happened to someone!

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-1 22:06
Mike (again again):

<< We probably need to consider how to transition to this system. >>

The way I transitioned was to start again from scratch, using the "enter a task when you think of it or it comes up in the normal course of work" method. I appreciate not everyone may want to do this.

Reply by Mike

2010-02-1 22:08
Mark,

I've started working with the system and though I have not been through a month cycle yet, I can see that since one is always working ahead, many of those tasks should have been done before you get to that day. My first impression was wrong because I did not quite understand the description. Yeah, poor planning ... I never do that ;-)

Reply by Jay

2010-02-1 22:09
I think using a calendar is a great idea because it allows one to see how much work one has committed to on any day and allows one to tackle tasks earlier,on days that have relatively more discretionary time.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-1 22:12
Christian G:

<< • Daily recurring tasks: have it on today’s page, finish it and cross it off, put the next instance on tomorrow’s page (not the page which is one week from today) >>

I think it makes it unnecessarily complicated to do that. It gives you three different ways of remembering to enter tasks instead of just two. And anyway remember that the dates are the expiry dates not the dates you actually do the task.

<<• Tasks with a deadline: I would put them on the page for the respective deadline date >>

If you do that it will prevent you from using the re-numbering method I described in one of the comments for when you miss some days completely due to trips, holidays, illness, etc.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-1 22:15
Ken:

<< OK, isn't this really as simple as:

<< + New tasks get entered on the list with a 30 day expiration period.
<< + Re-entered tasks get entered on the list with a 7 day expiration period.
<< + Unactioned tasks expire after 30 or 7 days, respectively, and simply get deleted.

<< I think referencing a calendar confused people when these three rules seem to sum it up. Thoughts? >>

Apart from anything else, I think a diary/calendar gives a powerful visual stimulus which is absent from a list.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-1 22:20
David:

<< I take it one enters tasks that have to be done today on today's date? >>

No, all tasks should be entered either at the 1-week or 1-month point. You are just as likely to do a task today if it is at 1-month as if it is at 1-day. I've done all but 4 of the 26 tasks which I put on 1 March today.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-1 22:25
Simon H:

<< I think this whole thing has become a joke. >>

The whole idea of releasing it in a relatively unfinished form was to get people's comments. And in fact there hasn't been a much greater volume of comments than there was for the original AF when that was released in January last year.

Reply by Pam Phillips

2010-02-1 23:37
This long-time lurker is in. As for transitioning, I'm going to copy my existing tasks to one month after the day I originally added them.

Reply by Gerry

2010-02-1 23:42
I am a bit confused.

1. Why bookmark today if you only enter tasks one month and one week out.

2. The issue I see is that March 1 is the 30 day out date now, but come February 22, it will be the one week out date, so I now have a mix of items on this page. Is there a need to note the difference, or just that if the page is dated prior to today, everything is dismissed.

3. If I understand this correctly once I have done this system for a month, I will be reviewing 30 pages of tasks potentially? So on March 1st to keep a task alive regardless of when it was entered on that page, I would move it forward one week?

Thanks

Gerry

Reply by Tijl Kindt

2010-02-1 23:59
One thing I like about the automatic dismissal is that while with AF4 you can leave it be for a few days and pick up afterwards without any major complications, doing the same here with AF5/DIT2 will force you to recognize that while you are leaving it be, you are letting several tasks expire without really knowing which.

So basically it will encourage you to interact with the system every day which will in turn force you to utilize it to its full potential.

Reply by Mike

2010-02-2 0:11
Gerry,

>>> 1. Why bookmark today if you only enter tasks one month and one week out. <<<

Because you might still have tasks that you entered a month ago or worked on and left incomplete a week ago.

>>> 2. The issue I see is that March 1 is the 30 day out date now, but come February 22, it will be the one week out date, so I now have a mix of items on this page. Is there a need to note the difference, or just that if the page is dated prior to today, everything is dismissed. <<<

No, as with AFs 1-4 a task is a task is a task. You don't distinguish between one entered but never worked on and one which was worked on and reentered. So there is no "mixture" to worry about.

>>> 3. If I understand this correctly once I have done this system for a month, I will be reviewing 30 pages of tasks potentially? <<<

Yes, you will have as many as 30 days open at any time ... today and up to 30 days forward, but unless you are doing nothing, you won't have "30 pages of tasks" ... there may only be one or two tasks left on some pages. Most likely you won't have all that many tasks left.

<<< So on March 1st to keep a task alive regardless of when it was entered on that page, I would move it forward one week? <<<

Yes, that is true of any page. The only page you enter tasks on are:

- + one week for reentered tasks
- + one month for new tasks

though Mark would probably say that you don't move tasks forward without working on them.

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2010-02-2 1:03
Seems to me the simplest transition is to just write March 1 on top of your existing AF list, and treat it as such. If you work on some of these items they get crossed off and possibly moved to today+7 = Feb 8.

Reply by Steve

2010-02-2 4:14
For me, the drawback to this new system (and it was also a drawback to AF in every configuration, but not to the old DIT), is that you still need a separate calendar for tasks that are due on a certain date.
The idea that a time management system can't handle tasks with a clear due date seems to me a flaw.
I know it's possible to juggle two calendars but I like the simple elegance of the old DIT which allowed me to use just one.

Reply by Seraphim

2010-02-2 5:24
Hi Steve,

I think AF (and this new system) handle due dates just fine. Enter the task, and just put the due date in parentheses or something:

- Task (due 2/15)


You *do* need a separate method to handle work that CANNOT BE STARTED yet -- if you put that kind of thing into AF, it clogs up the works, and I'd imagine it's the same for this new system. But those tasks can easily go into a standard tickler system such as Outlook tasks or a 43-folders setup. When the task appears in the tickler, just ask yourself if you can start yet. If yes, add to the list. If not, throw it back into the tickler for a later date.

Reply by Klaus

2010-02-2 7:41
DIT - the new and the old...

I tend to agree with Steve two posts back. One of the beautiful ideas behind DIT in my view was the factual journaling of your day. Even though for planning purposes I always prefer a weekly calendar, after I entered the appointments in the DIT diary this would enable me to see at a glance how much I could attempt to do on any given day.

An e-Mail with a two hour job would come in today. I would immediately see that I am travelling tomorrow, therefore unable to work on this until the following day and this would be where I enter it. Of course certain things could be scheduled even further in advance. This elegance I very much admired in DIT. Also certain periods like weekends could be reserved for the kids or, if necessary, switched over to work periods.

However you look at it, this new system seems to be more of a motivational, psychiological ploy than the planning system that was DIT. I was really hoping for an addition in order to better handle interruptions for example. Also the recurring task bit is in my view not handled successfully. And finally I like to have all my eggs (tasks and appointments) in one basket. To have two separate diaries with different usage seems to confuse the issue.

Klaus

Reply by Leon

2010-02-2 8:10
Hi Klaus, I'm not sold on the system myself but I think it's perfectly possible to use a page per day diary for appointments and tasks just like in DIT. What are your thoughts on this?

Reply by Pascal

2010-02-2 9:14
@Mark:

Your new system sounds very good on paper (I mean both : on paper and in theory!)
However, one question about delegation (delegated taskes). Do you add them as "do control that xxx did it" tasks, as usual tasks? (one month ahead, then re-enter 1 week ahead)?

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-2 9:28
Gerry:

<< 1. Why bookmark today if you only enter tasks one month and one week out. >>

Because today's page is the first page of your list. So when you get to the end of the list you need a marker to find the beginning again.

<< 2. The issue I see is that March 1 is the 30 day out date now, but come February 22, it will be the one week out date, so I now have a mix of items on this page. Is there a need to note the difference, or just that if the page is dated prior to today, everything is dismissed. >>

There's no need to note the difference though if you wish to all you need to do is to draw a line at the end of each 1-month page's tasks at the end of the day. In the final week all tasks are treated the same, including the lapsing of tasks once they pass the "today" point.

<< 3. If I understand this correctly once I have done this system for a month, I will be reviewing 30 pages of tasks potentially? So on March 1st to keep a task alive regardless of when it was entered on that page, I would move it forward one week? >>

Only if you've done some work on it. Otherwise it lapses.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-2 9:30
Mike:

<< though Mark would probably say that you don't move tasks forward without working on them. >>

He would indeed. If one doesn't take the lapsing of tasks seriously the whole point of the system is removed.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-2 9:35
Klaus:

<< Also the recurring task bit is in my view not handled successfully. >>

Actually my experience so far is that it's brilliant at recurring tasks. Over the past three days I actioned the task "Comments" twenty-one times (not including this time), and every time I did it according to the rules.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-2 9:41
Pascal:

<< However, one question about delegation (delegated taskes). Do you add them as "do control that xxx did it" tasks, as usual tasks? (one month ahead, then re-enter 1 week ahead)? >>

It depends on the interval. If it's a task that recurs after more than a couple of days, it's best to regard it as a new task and re-enter it at the 1-month point. For tasks recurring less often than weekly, it's best to put them in a reminder (Outlook tasks, etc).

Reply by Klaus

2010-02-2 9:54
Mark:

Point taken, I have never been really happy with AF in this regard. It may be due to the fact that I sometimes do not look at my list for days for various reasons. The other stuff that I mentioned is actually more serious in my view. The sheer elegance of sending reminders to yourself like in a tickler (which I never liked as a separate entity) is missing in comparison with DIT.

Leon:

I used an A5 diary (the red one from Moleskine) in exactly this way last year and I am setting up my Filofax for something similar. There is a relatively small monthly planner that I use for overview and pocketability. My calendar is a day per page where more detail is entered like start / stop times of appointments. The to do items then go around these reserved time blocks. This will also allow me to fit in the rest of my family and to reserve time for various kid events, playing and of course time with my wife.

The result is a day to day overview on how I plan to use my time and how I used it in the past. What came in surprisingly and what was I able to accomplish in an orderly fashion. What I still don't like in this system is rescheduling. I do use a pencil for everything but it is still messy.

And you also need to work in a very disciplined manner, otherwise you will get behind and will keep on chasing backlogs. That was one of the nice things of the AF system. If something didn't get done now it would still be on the list for some more time to come. There is no false sense of urgency. Things would only get tackled if they stand out for whatever reason, in DIT things get tackled because they got in yesterday!

This is why I want the best of both! Mark, do you read? :-)

Reply by Damien

2010-02-2 10:10
Looking at the new system I think I stay away from it, to avoid the confrontation with all those empty pages.
Was it not for the difference 'new tasks' - 're-entered tasks', I have the impression that setting an automatic dismissal 7 days back would allow an easy conversion from AF to DIT2. New tasks could be processed by giving them 4 lives (4 weeks) where a 're-entered task' has only 1 life. A 'new task' could then be pushed 3 times forward by the dismissal line. This would give the greater simplicity of an automatic dismissal, hampered by a complex - messy - unusual 4 lives dismissal.
On the other hand using a calendar where open - actionable items stand on today and the next 30 days is also unusual. But DIT2 looks forward where AF looks backward.

Reply by Mike

2010-02-2 11:43
Mark,

I think by "recurent tasks" some people (myself included) think of tasks that happen at SPECIFIC times or intervals. IOW, every day at 0800 I attend a staff meeting. Every Thursday I vacuum the livingroom. Every April 15th I mail my taxes (though that last is more of an "appointment".) The feeling is that some people want to be reminded ONLY when the task is due, not over and over and have to decide when to do it.

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2010-02-2 11:50
Mike:

«I think by "recurent tasks" some people (myself included) think of tasks that happen at SPECIFIC times or intervals. IOW, every day at 0800 I attend a staff meeting. Every Thursday I vacuum the livingroom. Every April 15th I mail my taxes (though that last is more of an "appointment".) The feeling is that some people want to be reminded ONLY when the task is due, not over and over and have to decide when to do it.»

I would think stuff like that goes the the calendar/tickler, with every version of Autofocus, including DIT2/AF5.

Reply by Tony

2010-02-2 12:38
It seems to me that the electronic version of this system could be very different than the paper one. The basic requirements are that an unactioned task is automatically dismissed in one month, and that a task in progress is dismissed after one week. This could be done in an electronic system without explicitly using calendar pages. Whether this *feels* good to use is another matter.

I worked with David Allen at Actioneer many years ago, and his main innovation was that todos should *never* go on a calendar. In the case of AF5, the calendar is being used for an end date and not a start date, so this is not exactly a violation of David's principles. However, once you base your system on a calendar, the temptation to start using the calendar in a more traditional time-management manner is going to be very tempting. For me personally, keeping the calendar out of the system, yet having automatic dismissal, would be the ideal scenario.

Reply by Tony

2010-02-2 12:48
Just read all the blog comments, and saw that other folks have also been pondering and experimenting with the electronic version. And I was surprised to see that Mark was also chiming in here, since he usually seems to have little interest in the electronic implementations. Perhaps AF5 is the first version that specifically has different implementations for the electronic and paper versions, because each one offers distinct advantages.

Full disclosure: I am the author of FocusPad for iPhone, so obviously the electronic version is of interest to me :-)

Reply by Wowi

2010-02-2 13:09
I'm hesitating to switch to AF4 because I need to start working in a pre-structured diary which probably will have lots of empty pages and others which are overly full. Can't it be done without such a diary? Damien explained how this can be done by introducing the four lives of a new entry vs. 1 life of a re-entry. In the end, I need to manage two different lines of dismissal (1 week and 4 week), and the 4 week line dismisses everything, the 1 week line only specially marked re-entries. This would allow me stay with my book as before - and I will give it a try.
Wolfgang

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2010-02-2 13:13
«I worked with David Allen at Actioneer many years ago, and his main innovation was that todos should *never* go on a calendar.»

David Allen allows for todos to go on a calendar, but only if they have to be done on that day or at that time. His example in the book, IIRC, is "Call Susan re: dinner", which has to be done that day for dinner to take place. So he would put it on the calendar, though not on a specific time slot since it doesn't matter when he calls her, as long as he does that day.

«However, once you base your system on a calendar, the temptation to start using the calendar in a more traditional time-management manner is going to be very tempting. For me personally, keeping the calendar out of the system, yet having automatic dismissal, would be the ideal scenario.»

Personally I don't see a problem with having appointments/day-specific todos and AF5-style tasks in one book, as long as they are clearly separated. Franklin Coveys 2-page diaries sound interesting in that regard.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-2 13:19
Mike:

<< I think by "recurent tasks" some people (myself included) think of tasks that happen at SPECIFIC times or intervals. IOW, every day at 0800 I attend a staff meeting. Every Thursday I vacuum the livingroom. Every April 15th I mail my taxes (though that last is more of an "appointment".) The feeling is that some people want to be reminded ONLY when the task is due, not over and over and have to decide when to do it. >>

As Andreas rightly says in every version of AF that sort of task has gone in some sort of tickler (I use Outlook Tasks). That is if you need a reminder at all - who needs to be reminded that there's a staff meeting at 8am every day?

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-2 13:23
Wowi:

<< I'm hesitating to switch to AF4 because I need to start working in a pre-structured diary which probably will have lots of empty pages and others which are overly full. Can't it be done without such a diary? >>

I'm sure it can be done without a diary, but nevertheless I feel that the diary gives a powerful visual presentation which is lacking in non-diary versions. This is something that I'm appreciating more and more as I go on (now on Day 4).

Reply by Jim (Atlanta)

2010-02-2 13:38
Ok, I'm going for it. This is where my Levenger Circa comes in handy. I rearranged pages and wrote 2/9-2/28 on the top corners of pages, inserted a divider, then wrote 3/1-3/28 on the top corner of pages after divider. I put my list from yesterday on 3/1, crossed out one and re-entered it on 2/9 (since it's a book I'm reading for a class) and crossed out another completely. Now if I have this right I enter new tasks today on 3/2 and re-enter things on 2/9 as I cross off recurring tasks.

Now when I get to that book I'm reading again: if I read some today, I believe I'd cross it off and re-enter it again on the 9th, but if I don't read more until tomorrow, I'd cross it off and re-enter it on the 10th. Do I have that right?

And I gather I treat the things on "next week's list" like the items above the line in AF4 and circle through them first before going on to the items "next month's list" or just continue to treat them all like one big list?

So far it seems to make sense. It really does seem like a combo of AF4 and DIT. The open-ended aspect of AF4 with the added incentive of deadlines of dismissal to get me off my butt and do the things that linger too long. It took me a while to digest the idea that I'm not putting these things off any more than I was before, but putting a final deadline on them. It felt weird to write things I knew I had to do today on "3/1" but then I trusted that those items would "stand out" and sure enough, no worries there so far.

Thanks Mark!

Reply by Allison

2010-02-2 14:03
>>You *do* need a separate method to handle work that CANNOT BE STARTED yet -- if you put that kind of thing into AF, it clogs up the works, and I'd imagine it's the same for this new system.

I disagree. You can still enter a future something that can't be started yet. If you are using your list as intended, that future something won't POP OUT to you as something that can be worked on. But it's still there on your list. I like that those future somethings still get glanced over; it keeps them in my mind.

--Allison

Reply by vegheadjones

2010-02-2 14:12
I agree with Alison. Since the start of AF1 I have not used a tickler at all...

Reply by Allison

2010-02-2 14:20
And...
I think after reading through all the comments, that there is a lot of confusion between the calendar and the list.

It seems to me that even if you write "call Mom" on March 2 (which is what you would to today), when you are working on your list, you would SEE it, but you wouldn't DO it if you had just talked to her. It wouldn't stand out to you as something that needed to be done.

I am pages that have two columns: one side is a list with a space for checkmarks (which I greatly prefer to the crossing off idea) and the other column has time slots in 30 minute intervals. I use the time-slot side for appointments on their actual day and the list side for AF. When I am ready to work in the morning, I check the appointment side, then move on to "tackle the list" mode. If I have an appointment at 2pm, I set my phone alarm so I don't get lost and forget about it.

As for scheduling time with my kids and hubby -- I simply close the book. :-) I do understand the need for a reminder, sad as that is, to be with my kids. But I'm specific about it. Like my kindergartner who is learning to read... I have "read with T". And yes, it shows up on Feb 8, because I put it on my list yesterday Feb 1 (my day one) to begin with, read to him last night, checked it off and put it on Feb 8, one week out. Does that mean I won't read to him again until Feb 8? No way. Because it's on my list, I'll cycle through that, see it today, do it today, then re-enter it on Feb 9.

I didn't mean to be so lengthy, but I find it helpful when someone walks through their steps so I can really see how they do things, so I thought I'd give it a go.

I can't wait to see how the comments fly when we all hit "one week" and "one month" :-)

--Allison

Reply by moises

2010-02-2 16:12
Initial Impressions

I set it up with a Franklin Covey Compass Classic 2-pages-per-day Planner (US) Diary (UK).

1. I will slowly need to develop a surer way to distinguish between "re-entering" an existing task and "entering" a new task. If I have an ongoing project to purge my (real physical) file cabinet, and my next task is to purge the "Computer" folder, and I finish that task, do I re-enter the next task, which is to purge the "Consultants" folder, or do I enter a new task? It is all part of an ongoing project, so it would make sense to call it a re-entry and give it a 7-day deadline. But, it could be viewed as a new task in an old project, which would permit a one-month deadline.

2. I can see that either I will stick with the system and it will impose a rigorous discipline on me, or I will break down and abandon the system. In years past, I gave deadlines to all my tasks. And then I blithely ignored them. This new system is quite different from AF4 (and other AFs). In the AFs, I developed a habit of reading many books simultaneously. I might read as little as a page or two in a book, and then return to it 3-4 weeks later and read another page. With this new system, that will no longer be possible. And that is probably better. It really will focus me on a narrower range of active items. Of course, how I resolve the issue in number 1, above, will greatly affect how the system works. If working on an ongoing project qualifies for "re-entry" then I will be forced to limit (i.e. focus) how many projects I take on at any time. I see that I might be working more on fewer projects than I was in AF4. Again, this strikes me as a good thing, but I can't be sure until I try it.

3. This seems to be the first system since DIT1 that is effective for me for recurrent tasks. I never could get my recurrent tasks to integrate in the AFs. I always had to go outside the system. But I have incorporated them seamlessly in this new system.

In conclusion, I have mixed emotions. There is some anxiety. I can hear the clock ticking as never before, since I have a page that expires on 9 February and it is filled with items. On the other hand, I sincerely believe that I could seriously become more disciplined if I am able to stick with the rigid deadlines this new system will impose on me.

Reply by SimonW

2010-02-2 17:52
Moises,

Re point 1 - it really depends what you think will motivate you better and that may vary from one project to another.

You can manage that project at the project level by continually re-entering the project name on the list, in which case you would re-enter 7 days away. Or you could write the next task on the list 30 days away. It's really up to you.

I use both approaches. Across my projects I have some that work better by just entering the project name (and possibly having a separate list of tasks for the project) and others that just have the next thing to do.

Of course re-entering the project name 7 days away means that you will be forced to work on it more regularly (or dismiss it).

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-2 18:02
Jim (Atlanta):

<< And I gather I treat the things on "next week's list" like the items above the line in AF4 and circle through them first before going on to the items "next month's list" or just continue to treat them all like one big list? >>

The whole thing is treated as one big list. You don't circle round any individual pages. Once you've been going for a month your list will be spread over 31 pages.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-2 18:08
Moises:

<< I have a page that expires on 9 February and it is filled with items. >>

But these are all things you have done some work on today, right? So there shouldn't be too much resistance to keeping the movement going.

Reply by moises

2010-02-2 18:47
Mark,

Of course. Today is easy. There are no deadlines till a week from now.

Like I said, so far, so good.

At the risk of being trite, we have to weigh the costs and benefits. The beauty of D2A5 is the looming deadline. But, sometimes, my job really turns on me in unexpected ways. We get very busy, or a key employee is hospitalized, or . . . you get the picture. And then, for a few days, or a few weeks, most of my projects get put on hold as I tend to whatever is urgent.

With AF4, I put my list on hold. And, when I am ready to come back to it, there it is waiting for me.

With D2A5, the unstoppable march of time destroys everything lurking in its path. When I finally come up for air, I'll have to start from scratch.

But, it might just be worth it. Possibly, D2A5 will develop my disciplinary muscle to such an extent that I'll mostly be working on stuff that has no deadline for at least 7 days. So, I'll usually have a pretty big cushion allowing me to absorb the unexpected urgent emergencies without suffering too much damage.

Reply by Lillian

2010-02-2 20:42
Moises - in the comments to the blog post (2nd page of the comments I think) there's a comment about using numbered pages instead of dated pages. You'd enter tasks on "current page +7" or "current page+30" and move forward one page a day. That might help the "put list on hold" issue.

Lillian

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2010-02-2 22:20
In the end, I don't think dates have anything to do with this system. Think of it this way:

* Start with a 31 page notebook.
* Every morning, tear out the first page and recycle it. Add a new page at the back.
* Whenever a new task comes to mind, write it on the last page.
* Flip through the pages looking for a task to work on.
* Whenever you work on a task, on any page, cross it out. If you aren't done, rewrite that task on page 8.

Reply by Mike

2010-02-2 22:41
Alan,

Good catch. I spent some time yesterday and today wrestling with dates and how to manage them. It really should be easy, but in practice, at least in the beginning, it can get confusing. It may be that the simplest approach is 30 (or however many seems right) pages is the way to go. I can see that even numbers are not necessary ... just a clip on the seventh (or however many seems right) page.

As usual, you have grasped the essence of it which eluded me ;-)

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-2 23:40
Alan:

<< In the end, I don't think dates have anything to do with this system. Think of it this way:

<< * Start with a 31 page notebook.
<< * Every morning, tear out the first page and recycle it. Add a new page at the back.
<< * Whenever a new task comes to mind, write it on the last page.
<< * Flip through the pages looking for a task to work on.
<< * Whenever you work on a task, on any page, cross it out. If you aren't done, rewrite that task on page 8.

That sounds really good.

One suggestion: you could make it even simpler by saving the necessity for step two if you used a notebook and dated the pages.

Come to think of it, I believe you can actually buy them ready dated.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-2 23:44
Mike:

<< I spent some time yesterday and today wrestling with dates and how to manage them. >>

I'm not really quite sure why everyone is having such a problem with the dates. To me it seems quite simple. One week is the same day of the week as today. One month is the same number of the month as today.

What is difficult about that?

Reply by ubi

2010-02-2 23:59
Alan Baljeu wrote: " In the end, I don't think dates have anything to do with this system. Think of it this way: Start with a 31 page notebook. Every morning, tear out the first page and recycle it. Add a new page at the back. Whenever a new task comes to mind, write it on the last page. Flip through the pages looking for a task to work on. Whenever you work on a task, on any page, cross it out. If you aren't done, rewrite that task on page 8."

This is brilliant. If I decide to try this new method, I think I'll use 31 index cards. I love the idea of tearing up "today's" card. And flipping through cards seems more natural than paging through a day planner (U.K. "diary"). I will probably date the cards, however, both to keep my place and to allow resorting when they fall and get scattered. By coloring today's card with a highlighter and putting a paperclip on card#8, I'll be able to keep my place.

Alan's insight also exposes the arbitrariness of the next-week and next-month deadlines. I imagine that some people would like shorter or longer time periods. Still, 31 cards fits in a back pocket nicely enough.

I wonder if Mark thinks there is something important about having all the "dead" pages in the diary and carrying it around all year...

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-3 0:24
ubi:

<< Alan's insight also exposes the arbitrariness of the next-week and next-month deadlines >>

It does? How?

<< I wonder if Mark thinks there is something important about having all the "dead" pages in the diary and carrying it around all year... >>

Well, exactly the same applies to an appointment diary or to a book you are reading. Do you tear the pages out of them once you've used/read them? Maybe you do.

Perhaps you'll understand it better after the first few times you have dropped your index cards and have to rearrange them all.

Reply by Alex W.

2010-02-3 0:38
I really don't know what to think of this new system (and therefore refrained from commenting up to now).

But re the dates issue, I have the impression that four weeks would be much more practical than one month. (1) This would solve the (micro-)problem of uneven month lengths (with February having only 28 days and most months having 31) and (2) I'd much rather not have my work tasks expire on Saturday or Sunday, keeping the synchronicity of the week day instead.

And yes, the mashup of a calendar/diary and a task list is a problem for me, too.

Alex

Reply by Mike

2010-02-3 1:56
Mark,

>>> << I spent some time yesterday and today wrestling with dates and how to manage them. >>

I'm not really quite sure why everyone is having such a problem with the dates. To me it seems quite simple. One week is the same day of the week as today. One month is the same number of the month as today.

What is difficult about that? <<<

Well, I guess if I knew what was the difficulty it might not be difficult. I don't know, the flipping around remembering what date I entered what task on is just confusing. I don't think that in the long run it will be a problem. Once I get the hang of it it will be easy enough.

If you remember, the first thing I wanted to change was to make the far out date one month rather than 30 days so I would be less confused about what date was 30 days from today. I agree, a pack of cards is more likely to fall on hard times than a book, but Alan's suggestion really does make it simpler ... you don't even need the pages numbered, if you don't want to have numbered pages. You just find the 30th page ahead and mark it with a clip and enter tasks there. You mark the one 7 ahead with a clip then the system runs without reference to dates or page numbers or anything. Just move each clip ahead one each day and throw away the first page.

Also, this answers the problem people see of putting the system aside for a few days then trying to restart it. With dates it seems as if it would be a mess to restart. Without dates, you just pick it up and restart it as if it were the next day.

But that was a good one about how one could find a pre dated book ;-)

Reply by Daniel

2010-02-3 3:47
If you want to get started but you don't have a diary handy, try here:

http://www.diyplanner.com/

Reply by MartyH

2010-02-3 8:58
My two issues are about what happens if you stop and need to restart and that for me it just seems odd to add something in the future that will already have expired by then.

I will have to reread what Mark wrote about renumbering in order to restart. I was just too tired to follow it the first time. He also mentioned that it is easier to do than describe.

The one about something with a due date less than 30 days out seems easy: Add it on the last day it can be done. Include the due date in brackets which is what I do now in AF4 like this: [17 Feb]. If the date you originally write something (one month from today) is the expiration date, this just seems logical to me. I don't really understand why Mark is against this.

Now if we we don't number the pages (as Alan suggests) it wouldn't bother me that it is on the 30th page.

Our minds all work differently. This part has really hits a nerve with me for some reason. Does it matter that I am an engineer?

Reply by ds

2010-02-3 13:27
<
Come to think of it, I believe you can actually buy them ready dated.>>

Beautifully played, sir!

Reply by ubi

2010-02-3 13:50
Mark Forster asked: "[ubi wrote:] << Alan's insight also exposes the arbitrariness of the next-week and next-month deadlines >> It does? How?"

Yes. By thinking of page#8 and page#31 (or index card#s). When you realize you only need to handle 31 pages or cards, the question leads to "Why 31? Why not 25?" etc.

Mark also asked: "[ubi wrote:] << I wonder if Mark thinks there is something important about having all the "dead" pages in the diary and carrying it around all year... >> Well, exactly the same applies to an appointment diary or to a book you are reading. Do you tear the pages out of them once you've used/read them? Maybe you do."

No, but the already-read pages of a book aren't "dead" to me in the same way that crossed-off lists are, and I don't need to carry the current book I'm reading with me everywhere, for a whole year. An appointment diary has potential value for all the days of the year, both in planning and reviewing dates of events. In AF, we didn't need a 365-page notebook, and a pocketable one worked fine for AF4. So my question was really about whether you thought there was value in reviewing the old pages in this new system. If I understand your new system correctly, the old pages are truly dead, and the pages after today+31 cannot be used. So unless we combine functions into some type of reminder system + your new system, we're only using 8.5% of the pages.

Finally, Mark joked: "Perhaps you'll understand it better after the first few times you have dropped your index cards and have to rearrange them all."

Yes, perhaps. But I think I'll try it that way, as being able to keep something in my pocket, with enough room to write the lists, is a big advantage over carrying a non-pocketable journal or diary.

Reply by Jim (Atlanta)

2010-02-3 13:55
Mark,

"I'm not really quite sure why everyone is having such a problem with the dates. To me it seems quite simple. One week is the same day of the week as today. One month is the same number of the month as today.

What is difficult about that?"

I think I get why this is a problem at first for many and why Alan's idea of numbered rather than dated pages seems good at first blush (even though they're really the same basic method).

When you go into a fuller explanation of this new system (which I've been calling Forward Focus) you just need to make it clear that this "list calendar" has nothing to do with one's appointment calendar. It's not a problem for me because I use google's calendar for appointments and a notebook for the new system. It is undeniably strange to write something on my list that I know is "due" by the end of the week or so on a list that, at the top of the page, says "March 3rd" because by March 3rd I'd be in serious trouble for not doing it. It also feels strange to be writing re-curring tasks like "check email" on a list that has a date a week hence when you know you'll most likely be doing it in a couple of hours at the most.

So numbering rather than dating sounds like a fix to this kind of confusion. But I think you are right that since it's so easy to buy a calendar and start using it that it seems silly to make up a new way of doing it. We just need to try your method for at least a month and a new habit will form.

I also wasn't one of those people that had my list spread over 30+ pages before, so knowing I will soon be doing just that is a bit unnerving.

However, while I thought AF4 was the best, I did tend to leave things above the line of demarcation too long and the automatic dismissal of this new system is something I think will be of great benefit once people get used to it. As you always say: trust the system!

Like Alan, I am using my same blank notebook, but unlike Alan I simply jotted "2/9" and so on through "2/28" in the top corner of each page before a divider (which could be anything--a sticky note even) and "3/1" and so on after the divider so it doesn't feel like a calendar to me, just a different way of organizing the notebook I was already using.

Thanks,
Jim

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2010-02-3 14:08
Dated or not, each active page becomes more urgent as they approach the front of your list.

One tweak I would make to the dated approach arises because I like today's date to be a record of what I worked on today. By this system, Today+7 is the record of today's work (everything you work on gets re-entered 7 days from now), except tasks you complete don't get entered on that date.

To solve that, I might skew the dates backward so that I'm dismissing pages 7 days old, and re-entering worked-on tasks on today. I fear this might ruin the psychology of things because Today's date might feel like things I ought to do today when in fact by this adjustment last Wednesday contains the things I _must_ work on. Or maybe with the right mindset, all past-dated tasks will feel neglected and I won't put them off 7 days at a time because every one of those will make me feel guilty for not getting them done on time :-) I understand though "done on time" is not an element of this system, and the dates are more psychological than obligations.

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2010-02-3 14:14
Alan:

Another issue I see with that approach is that today+7 doesn't only hold tasks you re-added today, but also tasks you added a month-7 ago. At least it will when you've worked the system more than a few days.

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2010-02-3 14:39
You're right. Okay that doesn't quite work then. Back to the drawing board.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-3 15:48
Could I just remind people that the idea is to test my system out and THEN make suggestions, not to invent your own system and test that out?

If you haven't tried the original system, your comments are not going to be any use to me.

Reply by David Drake

2010-02-3 16:03
Here, here! I agree. The more I have studied Mark's new system, the more I am seeing the brilliance in it. As Mark posted elsewhere, the point of having only those two pages to add tasks is that they are now closed lists....and they come closer and closer to you.

I am also finding it easier to see really what I have on my plate and when a colleague or boss comes to me and wants me to take on another project, I can see what is looming in terms of tasks/projects....and how close they are to the do or die date. This is going to be very, very helpful!

Just my two cents worth...

-David

Reply by Jens

2010-02-3 16:15
On thing I wonder about:
Regarding an office-list, what do you suggest for weekends - every week incoming stuff for 2 days will die due to the rules...- because usually I'm not in the office on saturday and sunday. Or have I missed something?

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-3 16:17
Marty H:

<< The one about something with a due date less than 30 days out seems easy: Add it on the last day it can be done. Include the due date in brackets which is what I do now in AF4 like this: [17 Feb]. If the date you originally write something (one month from today) is the expiration date, this just seems logical to me. I don't really understand why Mark is against this. >>

Because:

1) It was one of the things I tried out when I was developing the system, and it didn't work at all well. Mainly I think because it destroyed the closed list aspect of the system, and therefore much of its effect.

2) The idea is to test out the system and THEN suggest changes, not to invent something different and test that out. If you haven't tested the system as written your comments are going to be useless to me.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-3 16:29
Jens:

<< Regarding an office-list, what do you suggest for weekends - every week incoming stuff for 2 days will die due to the rules...- because usually I'm not in the office on saturday and sunday. Or have I missed something? >>

Remember there are two types of task which will be on today's page:

1) Tasks which have been re-entered. If you are only working Mon-Fri, then you will only have re-entered tasks on Mon-Fri. So there is no problem with those.

2) Tasks which have been on the list for a month and which you still haven't done. Does it really matter what day of the week these expire on? If you were going to do them, you would have done them already.

I have two reasons for preferring a calendar month to a 28 day month:

1) Using a calendar month makes it easy to see which day is in 1-months time. if it's Feb 3 today, then the 1-month point is 3 Mar.

2) The calendar month is what the business world works for most purposes. It's one of the natural units of time.

Reply by SimonW

2010-02-3 17:39
Hi Mark,

Some early feedback. First off I really like the auto-dismissal, knowing that is coming towards me is keeping me more focused on progressing older tasks than the AF4 Closed List did.

I'm experiencing some resistance about wasted paper! I run this in a pocket sized filofax and so there is a lot of white space at the moment. However this is counter-balanced by the way the system is working.

I started by regarding my current AF4 pages (7) as 7th Feb rather than going to a clean list. The alternative, for me, would have been to put "Review old list" onto my 1st March page and I would then have transferred quite a few items, so I opted for the first approach to avoid that and also as I thought it would be an effective quick test of how I'm motivated by the dismissal aspect.

My stats at the moment are:
Feb 7. 68 (86)
Feb 8. 1 (2)
Feb 9. 3 (4)
Feb 10. 1 (3)
Mar 1. 5 (8)
Mar 2. 4 (4)
Mar 3. 12 (12)

Reply by SimonW

2010-02-3 17:48
Actually I've just converted the outstanding AF4 pages completely so I have a dated page for each day starting tomorrow. That'll bring the dismissal in earlier now.

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2010-02-3 18:04
I like that idea Simon. Although it is biased a bit by the difference in processing method, you get a feel of a full system out of the gate.

Reply by slothbear

2010-02-3 18:26
I'm feeling reluctant to make any comments, for fear they'll be useless. I get the idea of trying the system as written before mucking with it -- but all the brainstorming feels like a natural part of exploring a new system that was purposely not described in detail. The "what if" ideas are useful to me as I run with the vanilla system. Some reinforce why I shouldn't change the system. Others give me inspiration for making the system fit *me* even better -- the ultimate goal.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-3 18:38
SimonW:

<< I started by regarding my current AF4 pages (7) as 7th Feb rather than going to a clean list. >>

I can't understand why you did that. You have only given yourself seven days to action your complete list. If you were going to put the entire list in one batch it should have gone on Mar 7th.

Reply by Mel

2010-02-3 20:17
One question I have. Maybe I missed the discussion of this. Should there be any emphasis on which tasks to focus on? IOW, should you work first on the tasks you're writing down for a month from now, first on the tasks that will be expiring quickest, or do you just jump around at will? Mark are you adding tasks that must be done today to today's list? Or do you use a separate list or no list at all and just do them? I don't mean tasks that obviously go on a calendar, like something you have to do next Wednesday. I mean I write this post and I tell you that if I don't hear back from you by the end of the day, something AWFUL will happen. If you can't answer me right away, what do you do with that task, imagining that you're not OK with something awful happening to me. LOL

Reply by SimonW

2010-02-3 20:21
Mark:

<>

Indeed. Now you point that out I can see how that would have been better. Ho hum.

I've analysed why I did that and it went like this: the earliest page in my AF4 Closed List was started on 22/12 and so it seems like cheating to give it a one month grace period. Bizarrely flawed now I write it down.

Now I'm not sure whether to continue as I have it now or move the relevant pages to Mar 7th. What do you suggest?

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2010-02-3 20:30
New tasks are written next month regardless of due date. All tasks on all ~30 pages will be viewed today.
"Save Mel, due Feb 3" gets written on Mar 3, and if Mark is a good guy he'll make sure to accomplish that before today ends. Maybe he just gets started on this task, and rewrites it on Feb 10. It's still out there, and still ready for Mark to work on it some more today.

Reply by Simon H

2010-02-3 20:47
This is all FAR too confusing now - bring back a simple time management system, like the original DIT - this is just getting so complicated.

Reply by Linda

2010-02-3 20:57
Having been an enthusiastic experimenter of all of the AF variations as well as with DIT (my favourite) I've had a different reaction to Mark's latest invention. I've read the instructions, understood (I think) the principles behind the method and followed closely the discussions here.

However, I have not been tempted to try this one out yet - for the simple reason that I'm extremely reluctant to use a system that requires me to scan through up to 31 pages in order to figure out what I want or need to do today. Am I missing some salient point?

Reply by AndreasE

2010-02-3 21:34
:-)

It seems, instead of becoming more productive, we all are becoming productive inventors of productivity systems...

(Just a joke I couldn't resist to make. One of my rather unfavorable habits...)

Reply by Will

2010-02-3 22:17
Simon,

I came VERY close to making the same mistake. I think I would have redated the tasks to 30 days out (easy with Outlook tasks: move one and a single drag and drop for all the rest).

You have some other options:

1.Give the day you chose special treatment as an honorary month out (means you'll have to keep checking it as it slips back to 3 weeks in the past) Probably not Ideal. See also 3. below.

2. Prune back to a level you can reasonably expect to do in a week, Where necessary, replace all the tasks in a project/ role with a single "plan project/ role" task. When you execute that task, put the individual actions a month out.

3.Declare a backlog for all the tasks on that page and start afresh (effectively the same as 1. Better if you recognise it as a backlog and make it your Current Initiative)

4. Work like fury to clear a month's tasks in a week. Might be feasible if you can temporarily cut off the flow of new tasks.

Most of these seem excessive reactions to a simple administrative error. I'd only consider them if you want to take the opportunity to clear out your lists before starting the trial in earnest.

It's funny how I'm naturally thinking of the present as fixed while the tasks in the diary roll towards me. With AF2, it felt like I was frantically stumbling forward with the Inexorable Line Of Doom snapping at my heels. I rather like the idea of the clear eyed hero standing firm as he faces down the advancing hordes.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-3 22:21
slothbear:

<< I'm feeling reluctant to make any comments, for fear they'll be useless. >>

Very much the same thing happened when AF1 was introduced in January last year. There were loads of comments from people who hadn't actually tried the system as written but were going to adapt it before they tried it. Which meant of course that the system itself was in danger of not being tested at all.

It was only when we had a substantial number of people who had actually done it for a good period of time as written that we were able properly to assess what the strengths and weaknesses of the system really were.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-3 22:29
Mel:

<< One question I have. >>

Just one?

<< Should there be any emphasis on which tasks to focus on? IOW, should you work first on the tasks you're writing down for a month from now, first on the tasks that will be expiring quickest, or do you just jump around at will? >>

You treat it all the pages as one active list and cycle round it, always going in the same direction.

<< Mark are you adding tasks that must be done today to today's list? >>

No I add them at the 1-month point like every other task. That is actually the page on which most tasks get done in any given day.

<< Or do you use a separate list or no list at all and just do them? >>

No, it works perfectly well putting them at the 1-month point.

<< I mean I write this post and I tell you that if I don't hear back from you by the end of the day, something AWFUL will happen. If you can't answer me right away, what do you do with that task, imagining that you're not OK with something awful happening to me. LOL >>

I write it at the 1-month point and when I reach that page I take action on it. As I just said, that is the page which has most of the action anyway.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-3 22:32
SimonH:

<< This is all FAR too confusing now >>

Actually the system itself is simplicity itself, as you'll discover if you try it out as per the instructions instead of reading all the comments!

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-3 22:35
Linda:

<< However, I have not been tempted to try this one out yet - for the simple reason that I'm extremely reluctant to use a system that requires me to scan through up to 31 pages in order to figure out what I want or need to do today. >>

Many people had 30 or more pages in AF1 and it didn't seem to be too much of a problem for them.

In any case you don't have to scan through 31 pages in order to figure out what you want or need to do today. What you do is scan through the list in one direction doing the items that stand out for you. The number of pages is hardly relevant because you are only selecting one task at a time.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-3 22:41
SimonW:

<< Now I'm not sure whether to continue as I have it now or move the relevant pages to Mar 7th. What do you suggest? >>

Actually I made a mistake in my reply. I didn't mean Mar 7th; I meant one month from when you entered them - which presumably would mean Feb 28th.

What I suggest you do is transfer all the remaining tasks on the Feb 7th page to Mar 3rd, i.e. one month from today (or Mar 4th if you don't read this till tomorrow). It might be a good idea to weed them a bit while you're at it.

Reply by Mel

2010-02-3 22:48
Thanks, Mark. Yes, I just had that one question. For now. When I reach the page that says, "Ask Mark more questions about DWM," I'll be back. LOL

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-3 22:50
Mel:

<< Yes, I just had that one question. >>

Ah, I see. It was one question in four parts, was it??

Reply by SimonW

2010-02-3 23:12
Will:

Thanks but I agree rather extreme for an admin error.

Mark:

Thanks. Will do just that.

Reply by TK

2010-02-4 0:44
Mark, I was hesitant to use the system since it just appeared against the spirit of DIT-a to-do or must-do list. I gave it a shot, and even though it looks like I'm working on a weekly to-do list, I have to say not bad.
Now I'm eager to try playing with different intervals. What if I didn't put the large list a month out, but 3 weeks out or 5 weeks out? Or my 1-week list became a 4 day list. I wonder what motivates people to do the max work here?
I've also thought of adding an auxiliary list of minor tasks that I can refer back to when I'm bored. This auxiliary list would be composed of things I might like to do but really don't require doing them in the near future or dismissing them. A good example would be a book I'm contemplating reading.
Brilliant Sir, brilliant.

Reply by Avrum

2010-02-4 2:07
<>

Personally, the rules lose their mojo when I start mucking with 'em.

Reply by Seraphim

2010-02-4 2:10
Mark, do you think it might be worth it to restate the instructions again? It would give you an excuse to close this thread, if nothing else. :-)

Here are some things that I think need to be restated / clarified:

5. All active pages are treated as if they were one long list and you continue to circulate round them doing the tasks that stand out.

First - what is an "active page"? It's clear to me now that this means all pages between today and today + 1M. But when I first read the instructions, it wasn't so clear.

Second - "circulate round them" wasn't clear to me either. I got the impression this was an area where you wanted us to experiment and process the list, "circulating round", in whatever method made sense for us. So, I treated each page in AF1 fashion (less the AF1 dismissal rules); and I figured other people would come up with their own algorithm. Turned out this wasn't what you had in mind. Rather, you've now made it clear that you intended that we should go through each item in the list, beginning to end, and work on whatever items "stand out" / "feel ready to be done".


A few other things... How do you begin each day? It seems there are several things that need to be done:

(1) Dismiss/delete the tasks from pages before today's page.

(2) Experimental exception to (1), if you've been away from your list for a few days: "Cross out all the days between the last 1-month page you put tasks on and the current 1-month page. Then you renumber the first day you missed to today's date, and the similarly renumber the 1-week page, then each day renumber the next pages until you catch up. That's much harder to explain in words than it actually is in practice! For example if you are away for the next 2 days (Feb 2 and 3), when you come back 1) delete Mar 2 and 3, renumber Feb 2 to Feb 4 and Feb 8 to Feb 10." (I still can't figure out what that means, and it seems kind of tedious... :-)

(3) Start processing the list at the beginning of today's page? from the place you left off last time? ???

Reply by Ed C

2010-02-4 8:51
Right - I've taken the plunge and it seems to be going ok so far (although clearly I haven't got to the stage where items are starting to be dismissed yet).

I'm just using a notebook and writing dates along the top (bit of a hassle writing a month's worth, but now I just need to write in a new date each day).

I'm also religiously using 4 weeks (28 days) as the '1-month' point. Not much of a hassle working this out - I just move the 'bookmark' (folded down corner) forward by one day each day. As I mentioned elsewhere, this means that if the random gardening jobs I think of this Saturday as I watch the rugby ever get near to dismissal, the dismissal day will also be a Saturday and so I might have a chance of saving them from the chop.

Positives at the moment:
- Generally no single page (so far) ever has a huge number of uncompleted tasks, so I never feel overwhelmed when I turn to a new page
- I like the fact that, when I get there, there will generally be a 'bare minimum' of work I need to do to save tasks from dismissal - on really slow days saying 'I'll just do that minimum' might just be enough to get me started and for motivation to return
Negatives:
- Less effective as a filterless 'grass catcher' or task-dump, as you lose the benefit above, and also would run out of space on a day page
- I can see the process of physically turning through 28 pages might get irritating after a while

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-4 9:36
TK:

<< Now I'm eager to try playing with different intervals. >>

Why? You haven't experienced what the 1-month rule is like yet.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-4 9:40
Seraphim:

<< Mark, do you think it might be worth it to restate the instructions again? >>

Yes, I'm thinking of doing so in the next few days.

On the question of how to start each day: personally I start where I left off the previous day. There's no real need to cross out individually expired tasks. I intend to just put a line through expired pages, regardless of whether they've still got tasks open on them or not.

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2010-02-4 9:42
Mark:

<>

I understand you don't want people to change the rules before trying them out. So I just want to ask, is using 28 or 30 days fixed instead of a month close enough? Because its really easier to do digitally, and your reason for choosing the same day next month was ease-of-use on paper, wasn't it. I can change the DWM implementation in AutofocusAHK to make it exactly one month, if you think it's essential.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-4 9:46
Ed C:

<< Less effective as a filterless 'grass catcher' or task-dump, as you lose the benefit above, and also would run out of space on a day page >>

I use the 1-month entry point as a "task-dump" myself. As for not having enough pages, that's why I advised a large calendar/diary with sufficient room for two or three columns. But even then if a page fills up, then just carry on on the next one. So if I filled Mar 4th I would start writing the tasks in Mar 5th and they would count as being entered on that day. Of course if this happens all the time you need a larger book!

<< - I can see the process of physically turning through 28 pages might get irritating after a while >>

We'll see. I've got 11 pages now, and it's not a problem so far. Remember you are only identifying one task at a time, so the actual paging through at any one time is minimal.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-4 9:51
Andreas:

<< is using 28 or 30 days fixed instead of a month close enough? >>

As you rightly say, my main reason for preferring a calendar month is presentational. I used a 28-day month for one of my earlier attempts at this system and I was always losing my place. That hasn't happened while using a calendar month.

So I don't think it's essential for a digital implementation if that's easier, since presumably there won't be any danger of losing the entry point.

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2010-02-4 10:35
<>

Okay, thank you. Losing the entry point is no issue with my digital implementation, you just tell the system to (re-)add a task and it takes care of where to put it.

Reply by Ed C

2010-02-4 10:55
Mark:

<>

If you use some kind of marker for the 1-month point then surely you just need to advance it one page each morning?

I can see why a strict month might be easier if retired/self-employed/working from home. But for me I think the advantages of keeping entry points on the same day of the week far outweighs any downsides.

<>

I can see that. But to be honest, that was a significant part of my reluctance to start using the system. Having a compact, portable (A5), list was just too much of a benefit to give up in my view.

Although having said that, I don't generally 'dump' a lot of new tasks at once very often - So far I haven't added any more than around 15-20 'new' tasks on any given day (about half the page - leaving room for re-entered tasks later on). I just think it might be an issue with some people's work style, who may then be forced to 'up-size' their list!

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2010-02-4 12:55
Okay, I'm all in now. I took my AF4 list with its currently small closed list and spread the tasks across this week. I took the longish open list and spread those across the rest of this month. By mid-next week I'll start to feel the threat of task zombies moving in. Wish me luck!

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-4 13:10
Alan:

<< I took my AF4 list with its currently small closed list and spread the tasks across this week. I took the longish open list and spread those across the rest of this month. >>

Congratulations! But remember that what you describe is not the way I recommend entering tasks - so if it doesn't work please don't blame the system!

As I said to someone else earlier, if you insist on entering your entire AF list in one go then it should go in at the 1-month point. If it won't fit on one page then carry on to the next page. But personally I think it's better to start again from scratch and enter things as you think of them or as they come up.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-4 13:30
Ed C:

<< If you use some kind of marker for the 1-month point then surely you just need to advance it one page each morning? >>

The problem was that I kept forgetting to move the marker. But I don't have strong feelings about this. I just think that using a calendar month makes it easier to enter tasks, and doesn't make that much difference when the few remaining items are due to expire in a month's time. Add to that the fact that most business transactions work on a calendar month basis rather than a 4-week basis. (Sorry, I keep thinking up new reasons why I prefer it!)

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2010-02-4 13:47
Mark I'm just trying to simulate how the list might be after long use. You aren't going to have 100 tasks on day 31 and nothing on days 8-30. They will be spread out in order of when they arrived. That is what I have set up.

I did leave lots of room on the front end to be safe.

Okay I admit: I'm too impatient to wait 30 days to get to the dismissal stage and see it function.

Reply by Ed C

2010-02-4 14:02
Alan:

You don't have to wait 30 days to get dismissal in action - only 7. (Although in my case, at least 8, as I've already cleared the first page of 're-added' tasks).

Mark:
I guess we'll have to agree to differ on 28 days vs 1 month! As I said, I think a lot depends on the situation - personally I would dread having to save work tasks from dismissal on a weekend. I guess that might be an extra motivation on a Friday, but I think looking ahead a few days in that way would destroy some of the simplicity of the method.

Reply by gghays

2010-02-4 14:14
New system is working well for me in OmniFocus.
My setup is:
Each day is a Single Action Project labeled as 0208, 0209, 0210, etc.
The One Week and One Month open days are
named -->0211 and -->0304 to make them stand out. This labeling also sorts the open days to the top of the project picker on the iphone.
All tasks enter thru the inbox and are moved to the appropriate open day (7 days out or next month) whenever it feels right. Could be once or several times per day. Yesterday, I moved inbox items three times, but only after I was comfortable that a "same day urgent task" wasn't in the inbox.

At the start of a new day:
Any remaining inbox items are transferred to the appropriate open day,
A new Single Action Project is created for the new day next month named with -->mmdd format
A new Single Action Project is created for the new open list day next week named with -->mmdd format (if the project already exists for that day, just rename project to the -->mmdd format)
Rename yesterday's open lists by removing the --> characters.

If you want an Archive of prior days
Create a folder named "Dismissed" with status of "Dropped" and drag expired days into it.
Optionally, create a Single Action Project named "Completed" to be the default place to clean up tasks which were completed while they were still in the inbox.

Very easy, very light, no sorting required. Appointments and hard deadlines go into iCal

Reply by Trevor

2010-02-4 14:21
Will wrote:

"It's funny how I'm naturally thinking of the present as fixed while the tasks in the diary roll towards me."

That's the feeling I'm getting, too. I'm using this in Omnifocus on the iPhone. Items which expire soon (ie. in the next seven days) automatically show up in orange - neat!

Of all Mark's systems, this is the one that seems to work best with a digital implementation. I'm loving it.

Reply by SarahinYorkshire

2010-02-4 14:29
Okay, I'm going to try it and NOT read all the analysis beforehand! I got a diary for about £3.75 from Staples if anyone's interested but put off by the cost.

I think my only tweak will be to note when I actually do something because I'm hoping some patterns might emerge. I'm much better at doing things when they've become routine.

Wish me luck - I'm going in....

Reply by TK

2010-02-4 17:12
Mark:

Because I think that there may be more optimal intervals eventually--isn't that the beauty of this system? Not saying that 1 month won't turn out to be the optimal time frame for dismissal, but I think it's worth investigating.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-4 17:14
Alan:

<< I'm just trying to simulate how the list might be after long use. >>

The problem is that you may be simulating how the list might LOOK, but you're not simulating how it would FEEL. In DWM it's not just the position of the task that's important, but also its history, i.e. whether it's been committed to or not, how many times it's been re-entered, etc.

And as Ed C points out you don't have to wait 30 days for dismissal to occur. All the tasks at the 1-month point that you take action on will go down to 7 days when you re-enter them.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-4 17:18
Ed C:

<< personally I would dread having to save work tasks from dismissal on a weekend. I guess that might be an extra motivation on a Friday, but I think looking ahead a few days in that way would destroy some of the simplicity of the method. >>

I'm happy to agree to differ, but I would point out that the only tasks that this is going to apply to are those that have been on your list for a month without any action being taken on them. Since you're scanning through the entire list all the time anyway, you don't need to "look ahead".

And I've cleared the first three pages of tasks, so no dismissal threatens until Monday at the earliest!

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-4 17:24
TK:

<< Because I think that there may be more optimal intervals eventually--isn't that the beauty of this system? Not saying that 1 month won't turn out to be the optimal time frame for dismissal, but I think it's worth investigating. >>

Yes, but you were talking about investigating different intervals NOW (or at least that's what I understood you to mean). By all means experiment with different intervals eventually, but you can't claim to have evaluated the 1-month interval until well over one month has passed.

Reply by Christian G.

2010-02-4 17:30
Mark wrote:
"Could I just remind people that the idea is to test my system out and THEN make suggestions, not to invent your own system and test that out?
If you haven't tried the original system, your comments are not going to be any use to me. "

Point taken... I will stay shtum and use the system as described by you.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-4 17:40
Christian:

Well done!

Reply by Mike

2010-02-4 18:00
A few quick comments on how I'm doing so far:

1- I "feed" tasks from my old AF4 book into the 1 Month page a few at a time. I pick the ones that seem the most urgent/important. This should give me a "spread out" effect and each task will have the full 1 month trip.

2- I am having trouble keeping track of where I am. When I reenter a task I sometimes put it at the end instead of the 7 day page. It is not that I'm really that dumb, it is just that I get confused when I'm working. (O.K. Mark, maybe I AM just that dumb ;-)

3- I don't ,know how you are handling the different number of days in the month but I'm just using the same day as today but next month for my entry point. IOW, I will not enter anything on the 29th, 30th, or 31st of March until March 28th, etc. when they will take reentered tasks.

4- I like the effect of moving forward toward the new tasks rather than continually looking back. This is clearly a psychological effect but I do like it.

5- The "drop dead" aspect of dismissal in this system is really more effective than the previous dismissal method. I don't see why it SHOULD be that way, but it is.

6- I started using another Composition Book, but I decided to use a smaller Circa ring book. It gets me back to a smaller format for one thing, but for another, there is a kind of feeling of finality in taking yesterday's page OUT of the book (and filing it elsewhere). There is no looking back unless I want to get another book from the shelf and fish out an old page. I keep the pages for reference and to provide me with a someday/maybe list but I'm not that motivated to rummage around in the archive book. I'm thinking I might do that only once every month or two, at most.

7- Since my book is a smaller format and has 25 lines I divide the page in half to give me 50 "slots". If I need more I think what I will do is use one sheet (rather than one page) per day. This also will simplify the bookmark system and archiving system. As it is now, with two dates on each sheet, the processes of moving the bookmarks and archiving is just a tad more fussy. So if I use both sides of the sheet I'll have 100 small slots or 50 larger ones, depending on how this all shakes out.

8- The other advantage of the Circa system is that I have other scheduling and calendar sheets in the same book that I can add, remove, and move around as necessary. So with the single book I can more conveniently carry, I have everything I need for scheduling in one place. Nice.

9- Lastly, I think that in the long run it won't mater to the mechanics of the system on the numbers of days chosen. Since I'm using dividers to separate "today", "reentry", "entry", they can be pretty much anywhere I want. I can even go to Alan's idea of not using dates. We'll see how it shakes out.

But that is the report for the first couple of days or so.

Reply by Allison

2010-02-4 18:40
I really am loving this system. I am using a 3 ring binder and one-page-per-day calendar/list system. It has the time slots in half hours on the left, and plain old lines for a list on the right.

I am extremely dangerous in office supply stores, but my new love is Post-It Notes "durable filing tabs". (I was not compensated for that comment.) They stand up to re-positioning and stick out just beyond the page, but not out of the 3-ring binder. Cool! AND they are color-coded. (my little office-supply infatuation grows...) So I have four tabs down my pages: Feb, +7, March, +30. I reposition the +7 and the +30 every morning. THAT is working GREAT!

I haven't come to a day where I use up all my lines yet, but I expect it will happen. I rarely crack open my AF book on Sundays, so week to week, I will always have a blank page. My thinking is, if, say March 4 fills up today, because lots of things occur to me, then I will just continue writing onto March 5. That keeps those ideas going onto the list in the order they came up, but then I won't have 85 things that have the potential of being dismissed all on the same day. And then Sunday, usually a blank day, will kind of be the catch up place, so I'm not really moving all those tasks down and messing up the beautiful dismissal system so much.

Along those same lines, as I have "transitioned" into this new list, I purposefully avoided dumping my OLD list onto the NEW for that very reason. I would have had over 100 things expiring on March 2! Yeeks! So I originally put "old AF list" on March 2 (because I started on Feb 2), and that meant for me to cycle through my old book and put 10 things that stood out for me onto Feb 9. (I actioned it, so it went 1 week out from Feb 2). I will keep RE-entering "old AF list" until it is all transferred over, 10 things at a time.

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2010-02-4 20:15
Mike, re #2 use colored bookmarks (or post-its, thanks Allison).
Blue for new on page 30.
Red for hot on page 7.

BTW, I favor using dates myself. I only mentioned the page number thing because people were thinking "if it says Feb 23, I won't do it until Feb 23".

Reply by moises

2010-02-4 21:52
Allison wrote: "I really am loving this system."

Me too! I never got this kind of feeling from all the AFs, though I did think that they were good systems. Rationally, I evaluate DWM and it is effective at managing tasks. Emotionally, there is something very powerful land attractive about it. My self-awareness seems to be soaring.

Reply by Mike

2010-02-4 21:53
Alan,

It is not finding the page that is the problem. I tend to forget what I'm doing because of the more complex rules. It used to be that you wrote ONLY at the end of the list ... no matter what. Now you have to think about what you are writing to decide where to write it. (I can't walk and chew gum either ;-)

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2010-02-4 22:37
The bookmarks are for visual cues what to do on the page. Blue=New Blue=New Blue=New. Write "ONLY NEW TASKS go here" on your bookmark. Hope it helps. Else nevermind.

Reply by Andreas Hofmann

2010-02-4 22:48
<>

Now you've done it, I have "Blue Moon, Blue Moon, blue moon" stuck in my head. :-)

Reply by Paul MacNeil

2010-02-5 2:42
Wow, this is beautiful, a paragon of simplicity and elegance. Just follow the rules, you'll be fine.

Reply by Allison

2010-02-5 2:58
Well, now I'm at the end of my day, home from work, kiddies to bed, and I have some time to "rip through the list" (what I usually do when there's nothing good on TV). Thought I'd check in to see what others are saying... And there aren't any new posts yet. Darn. :(

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-5 10:04
Allison:

<< Thought I'd check in to see what others are saying... And there aren't any new posts yet. >>

Just how often do you check the list???

Yesterday (midnight to midnight UK time) there were 120 new posts!

Reply by Annette

2010-02-5 11:53
I'm struggling to make this work for me, even though I think the dismissal procedure is quite powerful.

When I'm at work, I have short periods of time when I can do something, usually only one or two tasks, eg a phone call or an email, or going out to buy something at lunchtime. So I need to be able to see quickly what I have to do today, or would like to get done today. I don't have time to flip through up to 30 pages looking for a task that I can do in the five minutes I have at my disposal.

At home, when I potentially have more time to go through the list looking for tasks, it works better.

I know that Mark said that some people's AF lists were sometimes 30 pages long, but mine never were, and I could never work a system with that many pages. I need some way of seeing easily what I should be doing today without having to flip through so many pages. DIT didn't really work for me because I never knew how much time I'd have available in the working day, so my Will Do list was always a Will-do-if-I-have-the-time list.

I realise my working situation isn't very typical, so my experiences don't say much about how the DWM system can work for most people.

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2010-02-5 12:12
Annette, How about... use large pages and subdivide each page into multiple days. Fewer pages to flip, room for fewer tasks per day.

Reply by Will

2010-02-5 12:12
Annette,

At work, are you at a computer most of the time? If so, a list of open tasks permanently open down one side of your (second?) screen might be a practical solution.

Reply by Annette

2010-02-5 12:54
Alan:

I work with a small book (A6) because I need to to carry it around with me, so a book large enough to hold several days' tasks wouldn't be feasible for me.

Will:

Yes, I work at a computer, but I'm a trainer so what I have on my screen is projected onto the classroom screen. I only have one screen.

This is the first system where I've been tempted to abandon paper and pencil, because it would be easier to scroll through the whole list. But I don't have a PDA and would have to rely on being near a computer to see my list. And to be honest, I prefer to have something to hold and scribble on!

Thanks for your suggestions.

Reply by Will

2010-02-5 13:26
Annette,

How intriguing: my stereotype of a trainer doesn't have a lot of time to think about other tasks when they're in front of a class.

If you have a separate screen for desk-work, I'd strongly recommend that you use it as a second screen rather than closing the laptop. If not, do make sure you have a stand (could be a few reams of paper) and scrounge a keyboard for your laptop at least, so the screen is at the right height.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-02-5 13:27
Annette:

<< When I'm at work, I have short periods of time when I can do something, usually only one or two tasks, eg a phone call or an email, or going out to buy something at lunchtime. So I need to be able to see quickly what I have to do today, or would like to get done today. I don't have time to flip through up to 30 pages looking for a task that I can do in the five minutes I have at my disposal. >>

Most of this type of task will be found on just two pages:

1) The day before the 1-week point.

2) The day before the 1-month point

Reply by Mike

2010-02-5 13:34
Annette,

The smallest book I've used is a 3x5" vertical format spiral book. In one of those I got 15 tasks per page and so it could hold hundreds of tasks. It fit right in my pocket with a 1/2 sized pen stuffed in the wire. (a Zebra F-301, I think -- it stores 1/2 sized and then pulls apart to make a full sized pen when you want to write. It comes in a fine point.)

Circa also makes a 3x5 vertical format ring book where you can pull out and archive pages if that is your thing. With the wire spiral you just rip them out and trash them.

If you like, you could go with the hipster idea ... 3x5 cards clipped (a small "bear clip" works well) or punched to keep them together.

I went to the Composition sized book for a while and am now dropping back to a compromise between that and my 3x5 pocket spiral -- a Circa Compact. It is about 4x7 and has the removable and pages that you can file in an archive notebook. There are 25 lines per page and I am dividing the page in half to get two columns or 50 slots for tasks. The advantage to that system is that it is small enough to carry and I can put different pages in it and move them around. Lots of flexibility.

A simple steno pad is another option. If you are a Moleskine geek, they make a "Reporter's Notebook" that is vertical format and just a bit larger than 3x5.

Options, options, options ;-)

BTW, I realize that these books are not dated but you can either date or number the pages to get the DWM system going.

Reply by MartyH

2010-02-5 13:56
Annette,

It sounds like you only use your list for small tasks with larger tasks and projects being handled in another way. If that is the case, maybe the majority of your work and your time isn't really discretionary and this might not work for you. If one of the AF versions was working well, why not stick with it?

Reply by Annette

2010-02-5 14:04
Will:

I don't have time to consider tasks when I'm actually training - but I get about 15 minutes mid-morning and mid-afternoon, and then there's lunchtime. This is when I need to grab a task quickly and do it.

I don't have a separate screen or computer - just the machine I'm teaching from and demonstrating on. I could set up an on-line ToDo list and look at it at breaks, but I've realised that I really prefer a book, something I have access to all the time.

Mike:

I've been using an A6 Adoc book (like Circa) for a while now (it's about 3" by 5", I think). I like it because it's small enough to fit in any handbag, and light. I like the flexibility of moving pages around, and also keeping other things in the book, like notes and important info. The only problem is that I couldn't put multiple days on one page, as Alan suggested.

Reply by Annette

2010-02-5 14:11
Marty:

I break larger projects down into small tasks and attempt to control them in AF or this new system. I've been trying to get AF to work for me for a year now, and although the fact that I now have a ToDo list and work it in some fashion is a big improvement on what used to happen (ie semi-controlled chaos!) I always seemed to end up cheating the dismissal rules, for various reasons (one of which was laziness/extreme procrastination).

Maybe I just need to try harder...

Reply by Annette

2010-02-5 14:18
<<
<< When I'm at work, I have short periods of time when I can do something, usually only one or two tasks, eg a phone call or an email, or going out to buy something at lunchtime. >>

Most of this type of task will be found on just two pages:

1) The day before the 1-week point.

2) The day before the 1-month point >>

I think I see what you mean. But I also seem to have a lot on the 1-month point. Things crop up that seem to need to be dealt with today, though maybe I should be applying DIT principles to put them off until tomorrow where possible. At least the tasks should be clustered at or before the 1 week and 1 month points, I see that now.

Reply by Allison

2010-02-5 15:16
<< Thought I'd check in to see what others are saying... And there aren't any new posts yet. >>

From Mark:

<
<
Mark:
(blush)
First, I'm completely jazzed that I got a comment back from YOU! (absolutely star-struck, I am)

I checked before I left work for the day (5:30p my time) and then again at kiddies' bedtime (8:30p) I'm sure I'm checking WAY too often, but again, completely jazzed about all this and LOVING my productivity right now. It DOES always work that way (through my progression of Covey, GTD, then A1-4) that I get a lot done with a new toy... But this really has a different feel for me already and I can't wait until day 7 comes for me (a day after YOUR day 7) and to see what everyone else's experiences are like.

Reply by Allison

2010-02-5 15:20
<
<
Annette:
I, too, had that problem. What I found really works well for me is going ahead and doing the task anyway! It has occurred to me to DO it, because I see it over and over when I AM going thru my list, so it's on my mind.

When I have those few minutes to DO, I DO and leave my list shut. Then when I have more time to "work my list", I get to check off several things that already got accomplished. It motivates me to check off more.

I love the feeling of seeing an item and having the rush of "Hey! That's already done!" CHECK!